Mention the name of
Gluck, and almost every music lover
thinks of 'Orfeo ed Euridice' and maybe
some other operas from late in Gluck's
career. Most of his earlier compositions
are neglected. At the time Gluck composed
'Orfeo ed Euridice' (1762), he was already
a very successful composer of operas.
Most of them follow the then traditional
patterns of 'opera seria' or 'serenata'.
Like the 'opera seria' the 'serenata'
was about a serious subject-matter,
but was considerably shorter, and mostly
in two acts. It met the need for entertainment
and representation at court, and also
gave singers an opportunity to show
their skills.
Gluck composed three
works of this kind, of which 'L'innocenza
giustificata', called a 'festa teatrale',
was the last, written in 1755. Although
the style and form are traditional,
in more than one way it points in the
direction of what was going to come
with Gluck's opera reform, as reflected
in 'Orfeo ed Euridice'.
The subject of this
serenata is from Roman antiquity. The
cult of the goddess Vesta was one of
the most important state cults in ancient
Rome. According to legend the Trojans
had brought the sacred fire to Rome
on their flight from their city. The
fire was safeguarded by a college of
priestesses (the Vestal virgins) whose
vows bound them to strict chastity and
ascetic life. The libretto of 'L'innocenza
giustificata' (The proven innocence)
tells the story of the Vestal virgin
Claudia, who is accused of being involved
in a love affair with the young knight
Flavio. The consul Valerius informs
Claudia's sister, Maxima Flaminia, priestess
of the goddess Vesta, that her sister
is accused and must go before the Senate
to defend her reputation. Although Claudia
is confident that she has been able
to convince the Senators that she is
innocent, the Senate sentences her to
death. When she is informed that the
ship with the eagerly-awaited statue
of the great Idaic Mother has run aground
in the middle of the Tiber, she offers
to pull the ship single-handedly into
the harbour. When she succeeds in doing
so, she is forgiven, and the people
rejoice at the favour shown them by
the gods.
Although the libretto
is anonymous, it is likely that it was
written by Giacomo Count Durazzo, who
was the manager of the Vienna Court
Theatre. He was a great admirer of Gluck
and did everything possible to support
him. The birthday celebrations of Emperor
Franz I Stephan provided Durazzo with
an opportunity to invite Gluck to compose
a 'serenata'. But Durazzo will not have
written the whole libretto, only the
recitatives, the choral passages and
the closing scene. The texts of the
arias were all by the then famous librettist
Metastasio. In his liner notes, Ingo
Dorfmüller refers to the foreword
which pays respect to Metastasio, but
points out that the use of Metastasio's
texts was in fact a way to criticise
the products of his pen. The use of
a random selection of his texts implied
that these were exchangeable and not
related to the story of the libretto
for which they were originally conceived.
At several moments
Gluck moves away from tradition. The
'cavata' of Claudia, 'Fiamma ignota',
is cut short before it can take the
form of a da capo aria, when Flavio
bursts into the scene. Even more distance
from tradition is taken in the closing
scene with recitatives, an arietta and
the closing chorus, which is composed
attacca.
One can only agree
with Ingo Dorfmüller, when he concludes:
"Thus this apparently harmless 'festa
teatrale' contains a clear aesthetic
contrast of almost polemic intensity:
it is this that makes 'L'innocenza giustificata'
so special".
There are several moments
of great intensity in this serenata.
One of them is the last aria of the
first act, where Flaminia - accompanied
by two flutes - sings that if her sister
has to die she wants to die with her.
Another comes at the beginning of the
second act when Flavio wants to stand
by Claudia in her ordeal, but she insists
that he leaves her alone. At the end
of the first exchange the secco recitative
turns into a recitativo accompagnato,
which is then followed by a heart-breaking
duet.
Another highlight is
the aria of Valerio in the second act,
'Quercia annosa', where strings illustrate
the blowing of the wind: "An ancient
oak on a steep slope from the struggle
of hostile winds emerges more robust,
more healthy".
Some arias are also
technically very demanding, like Claudia's
first aria, 'Guarda pria', which contains
a lot of vocal acrobatics and asks for
quick shifts from one register to another.
One wonders why this
'festa teatrale' isn't more often performed
as it contains some brilliant music
and presents the singers with ample
opportunities to show their skills.
Reason enough to celebrate this recording,
which is a fine achievement from singers,
choir and orchestra alike.
Claudia is very well
portrayed by María Bayo, who
has no problems in meeting the demands
of the above-mentioned aria, even though
her intonation is a little suspect now
and then. I would have liked a less
wide vibrato on her part, but on the
positive side I noticed the right amount
of rhythmical freedom in the performance
of the recitatives.
The contrast between
her voice and that of Marina De Liso,
who sings the part of her elder sister
Flaminia, is just right. The same is
true for Flavio: Verònica Cangemi
gives a good interpretation of this
role. The interaction between Bayo and
Cangemi in the opening scene of the
second act is very lively and dramatic.
And in the duet their voices blend well,
and the timbre of their voices is just
different enough to tell them apart.
Andreas Karasiak is satisfying in the
part of Valerio, but his Italian pronunciation
isn't very idiomatic, and sometimes
he is a little stiff, in particular
in the recitatives. But he sings the
aria mentioned before, 'Quercia annosa',
quite beautifully.
The part of the choir
is very limited, just a couple of minutes
in total, but ChorWerk Ruhr does sing
it competently.
To sum up, this is
a enjoyable and recommendable production.
Hopefully we will hear more neglected
compositions by Gluck.
Johan van Veen