By a strange quirk
of fate, Vivaldi’s manuscript library
has ended up in the National University
Library in Turin. Sold to a collector
by Vivaldi’s brother, these 27 volumes
have passed through various hands and
now their contents are being made better
known by an ambitious series of recordings.
This set is billed as ‘Music Sacra Volume
4’ and describes itself as ‘Solemn Vespers
for the Feast of the Assumption’.
Though Vivaldi wrote
a lot of sacred music and contributed
a number of psalm settings for vespers,
no complete cycle of vespers music by
him survives. This is something that
seems to worry musicologists so instead
of giving us a 2 CD selection of Vivaldi’s
sacred music written for double choir
and double orchestra, we have this putative
reconstruction of a vespers service.
In the 18th
century, vespers was a highly important
service. Along with many composers Vivaldi
contributed fine settings of the psalms
needed and took advantage of the situation
to create highly elaborate settings.
The core of this disc is a group of
psalm settings for double choir and
double orchestra; the missing items
being made up from other settings.
The programme opens
with the Concerto in F major for 2 violins,
an isolated movement which is used as
a sacred overture. This is followed
by the Responsorium, ‘Domine adiuvandum
me festina’ for soloists, two choirs
and two orchestras. In the Gloria Patri,
Roberta Invernizzi contributes a stunningly
lovely solo.
The first psalm, ‘Dixit
Dominus’ is preceded by an Introduzione
sung in lieu of the antiphon. This Introduzione,
‘Ascende laeta’ for soprano and strings,
consists of two arias linked by a recitative.
The arias demonstrate the problems inherent
in singing some of Vivaldi’s virtuoso
vocal music. The technical effects required
can mean that the singer is in danger
of sacrificing tonal beauty for the
sake of virtuoso technique. This is
something that I think happens with
Cecilia Bartoli and Roberta Invernizzi
is a little guilty of this. The Dixit
Dominus itself, for soli, two choirs
and two orchestras is a tremendous piece
which deserves to be better known. The
choir and instrumental ensemble of Concerto
Italiano give a brilliantly incisive
performance. Anyone who has ever been
to one of their live concerts will be
familiar with the group’s lively and
infectious performance style. This style
is eminently suited to much of this
music.
The next psalm is ‘Laudate
pueri’ here performed in a setting for
soprano and orchestra, a lovely multi-movement
work which is well sung by Gemma Bertagnolli.
The first disc concludes with the short
psalm ‘Laetatus sum’ in a short lively
single movement for choir and orchestra.
The psalm Nisi Dominus
is performed by contralto, Sara Mingardo
and orchestra. Again Vivaldi shows his
skill in producing a varied multi-movement
work for just one voice. In this piece,
Mingardo’s voice sounds overly bright
in the upper register and at times she
could be mistaken for a counter-tenor.
But there is no mistaking the style
with which she sings this music, nor
the shapeliness that she brings to the
line. The final psalm, ‘Lauda Jerusalem’,
is performed in a single movement setting
for two sopranos, two choirs and two
orchestras.
The recording keeps
the best pieces to the last with a tremendous
setting of the Magnificat and the deservedly
well known Salve Regina. The Magnificat
RV610a is for soli, two choirs and two
orchestras and receives a fine, enthralling
performance from the ensemble and all
the soloists. This is followed by another
violin concerto in lieu of the antiphon.
Finally the vespers reconstruction concludes
with the Salve regina for contralto
and two orchestras. I am not entirely
sure that the low tessitura of the piece
suits Mingardo’s voice which sounds
rather too rich and plummy, but she
sings with a fine understanding of the
music.
The reconstruction
also includes the various plainchant
antiphons needed, but here they are
given in arrangements by Rinaldo Alessandrini
which are intended to evoke the style
of chant performance prevalent in the
18th century. But, though
based on printed originals from Rome,
these are still speculative reconstructions.
That the music on this
disc is all given in stunning performances
means that one is inclined to skate
over the fact that the structure of
the disc is entirely speculative. Not
only has Alessandrini has produced the
arrangements of the antiphons but he
has arranged the single orchestra items
to use the double orchestra forces that
form the basis of many items in the
disc. This is entirely convincing, but
I feel worried that so much work has
gone into constructing an edifice which
is not really of Vivaldi’s making. Did
we really need a vespers reconstruction?
The high standard of music making on
this disc should not blind us to the
fact that we would have been better
served by a selection of Vivaldi’s superb
vespers music, recorded in versions
sanctioned by Vivaldi. The idea of a
complete cycle of psalms as a single
musical entity is a modern construct
much beloved of modern performers.
Robert Hugill