MusicWeb International One of the most grown-up review sites around 2023
Approaching 60,000 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here Acte Prealable Polish CDs
 

Presto Music CD retailer
 
Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

BUY NOW 

Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS

Modest MUSSORGSKY (1839-81)
Night on Bald Mountain, arranged and orchestrated by Nicolai RIMSKY-KORSAKOV (1844-1908)
Pictures at an Exhibition, orchestrated by Maurice RAVEL (1875-1937)
Introduction to Khovanshchina (‘Dawn on the Moscow River’)
Atlanta Symphony Orchestra/Yoel Levi
recorded in Woodruff Memorial Arts Center, Atlanta, Georgia, 11-12 January 1991
TELARC CD-80296 [49'51"]

 

In its original form, Night on Bald Mountain (or Night on Bare Mountain, Night on the Bare Mountain, or St John’s Night…) is an extraordinarily original tone poem, riddled as it is with bizarre and provocative writing. Unfortunately, it is seldom heard or recorded in this version nowadays, probably for the same reason that Rimsky-Korsakov took to it. Mussorgsky’s score is crudely finished orchestrally, and includes, especially given its early date, 1866, baffling modernisms such as whole-tone scales, which don’t easily register with an unsuspecting audience. You may have noticed that I’ve listed the piece recorded here as "arranged and orchestrated" by Rimsky-Korsakov, whereas the CD, indeed everyone, as a general rule, refers to it as merely "orchestrated" by him. But be aware that Rimsky’s piece, for it is his piece, not Mussorgsky’s, bears little resemblance to the original. The always-progressive Mussorgsky’s discordant, rough-hewn thinking is ironed out by the essentially conservative Rimsky with a glossy, more gentlemanly, orchestral and harmonic palette. To crown it all there is a completely different ending!

I have a minor problem with Ravel’s orchestration of Pictures at an Exhibition too. Not that it doesn’t work. Far from it: it’s about as resourceful and as effective as orchestral writing can be! It’s more a matter of respecting a composer’s wishes. A strong case can be made for the original piano version, which needs and deserves no apologies - simply because it is uncharacteristic, or because it unduly stretches the performer. There really is no more logic in performing Ravel’s orchestration of Mussorgsky as often as we do than there is in routinely playing Schumann’s filling out of unaccompanied Bach, Mahler’s touchings-up of Beethoven, Mozart’s version of Messiah, or Stokowski’s Bach, rather than the well-proven originals: and yet none of these has become ‘standard’ in the way that Rimsky’s or Ravel’s arrangements of Mussorgsky have. However, whether you agree or don’t agree with me, I accept that it’s good to have these pieces, even in these manifestations, on our CD shelves.

In many ways, this kind of disc is a reviewer’s greatest challenge. It’s a good collection of pieces, although hardly generous - especially for a reissue - at five-eighths capacity; it’s well played; and it’s well recorded. But it doesn’t particularly excite me. Is it the mood I’m in? Is it where I’m sitting? The time of day? Or am I allowing myself to be irritated by the appearance of yet another non-Mussorgsky disc?

The facts. The Atlanta orchestra play with real distinction throughout. They have fine wind players, a glowing brass department, and a string section which matches the great European capital ensembles: Ravel’s saxophone, euphonium and muted trumpet solos are all one could possibly want. Levi is loyal to all of the composer’s, sorry, arrangers’, markings, and sews everything together most persuasively. I especially enjoyed the various linking ‘promenades’ in Pictures: they’re all nicely characterised. In terms of balance, accuracy, pacing or the painting of individual pictures, it’s impossible to fault. And - as we find so often with this label - Telarc’s recording illuminates every detail as well providing weight, depth and ambience.

There are perhaps half a dozen rivals (say Sinopoli, Reiner, Abbado, Karajan, Jansons and Gergiev?) which, here and there, offer more frisson, more glamour, more delicacy or more virtuosity than Levi: but you may have to buy all six to be absolutely sure. There may be some as spectacularly recorded (e.g. Maazel, also on Telarc); or more generously filled and even cheaper (e.g. Dutoit). You may even find an alternative which includes as atmospheric a Khovanshchina Prelude as we have here.

No more beating about the bush: this deserves a recommendation. I enjoyed it: and you’re unlikely to be disappointed. But do please give the originals the time (and financial outlay) they deserve: try Abbado (DG 445238-2) for an incomparably spooky St John’s Night on the Bare Mountain, and Pogorelich (DG 437667-2), Bronfman (Sony SMK89615) or - best of all? - Ogawa (BIS CD905) for Pictures at an Exhibition.

Peter J Lawson


Return to Index

Error processing SSI file