In the days of vinyl the Westminster label, coupled
to Britain’s Nixa records in the 1950s, became not only familiar but
also a force to be reckoned with. At the start its star conductor was
the German, Hermann Scherchen, though their stable of solo artists included
such distinguished names as Paul Badura-Skoda and Jean Fournier. With
the development of stereo sound in 1956 the catalogue began to broaden
with even greater names such as Rodzinski, Leinsdorf, Abravanel, Knappertsbusch,
Barenboim, Peerce, Stich-Randall, Forrester, Sills and Monteux. They
used the single microphone ‘natural balance’ recording technique and
their best work is now being reproduced on CD.
Pierre Monteux (1875-1964) was 87 when he made this
recording. He was a diminutive figure, corpulent with a Colonel Blimpish
appearance dominated by his bushy moustache, looking rather like a French
version of the British comedian Jimmy Edwards. Like his contemporary
colleagues Stokowski and Klemperer, and like Günter Wand today,
he was enjoying an Indian summer of a career while in his eighties (he
had just two more years to live). He started his childhood studies as
a violinist and his career as an orchestral player, and as a conductor
it was his appointment as conductor of Diaghilev’s Ballet Russes and
its association with Stravinsky’s music which launched him. The 1913
scandalous succès d’estime of the Rite of Spring
in Paris is well documented, then he worked with Debussy and Ravel to
create their new works, such as Jeux and Daphnis
et Chloë respectively. After a couple of years at the Met
in New York (1917-1919) he took on the union-troubled Boston Symphony
Orchestra for a while, and then in 1936 the San Francisco Symphony,
becoming a US citizen in 1942. In 1961, at the age of 86 and demanding
a 25 year-contract with the option of renewal, he was unanimously appointed
chief conductor of the LSO, with whom he works on this disc and who
clearly play their hearts out for him. His platform manner was unostentatious
yet authoritative, for he had a phenomenal ear and, though not an orchestral
trainer, he had one of the widest repertoires in the profession.
This is a revelatory performance of the Choral
symphony. It may not be entirely unblemished but there is lightness
of touch, transparency of texture, and some fine individual playing
from members of the orchestra as well as excellent singing from the
distinguished cast of singers and chorus in the finale. There’s no hint
of stodginess in Monteux’s widely varied choice of tempi, a striking
feature from the very outset. There is a point about eight minutes into
the Adagio where the music can meander and drift shapelessly as it fragments
into various solos taken around the orchestra (always a deathtrap moment
in the theme and variation principle) but Monteux avoids it cleverly
by a driving speed which nevertheless retains the space this music needs
for all the ‘small’ notes. In the famous finale the recording balance
is somewhat destabilised with all the singers rather distant, but on
the other hand a lot orchestral detail emerges, which is often obscured.
The tempi for the finale are on the steady side but Monteux gives it
all a sense of dignified, stately progression (Vickers strains at the
leash at ‘Jauchzet, Brüder’). The chorus provide a full-bodied
texture, just a hint of strain in the sopranos in the final stretches
(‘Sei willkommen Millionen’), the tenors (following their solo kinsman)
try to rush away (‘Such ihn über’m Sternenzelt’), the words as
clear as one can reasonably expect in this almost unsingable work. The
coda is thrillingly fast and conducted with the youthful exuberance
of a man sixty years his junior. If you don’t know this recording, you
should.
Christopher Fifield