Classical Editor: Rob Barnett
 

Music Webmaster
Len Mullenger: Len@musicweb-international.com

Save around 22%
with these retailers



Bedrich SMETANA
(1824 - 1884)
Ma Vlast/ My Fatherland
Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra Libor Pesek
Recorded Philharmonic Hall, Liverpool. May 1989
Antonin DVORAK
(1841 - 1904)
Domov muj / My Home. Overture Op 62a 10.02
Czech Suite. Op 39 23.01
Symphony No 4 in D Minor. Op 13 42.18
Czech Philharmonic Orchestra Libor Pesek
Recorded Dvorak Hall, Prague (2:1) May 1995. The House of Artists, Prague (2: 2+3) Mar & June 1989 Virgin Classics 7243 5 61739 2 7 CD1. 76.33 CD2. 75.20

The coupling on one Virgin double CD of works by Czechslovakia's two main national composers gives a well filled and generally recommendable offering. All four works are conducted by Libor Pesek, using two different orchestras, of which the Royal Liverpool Philharmonic shows up better than its Czech counterparts with a greater weight of string tone.

Disc One is a performance of the Smetana's Ma Vlast - the six sections in full, not just the two widely heard popular extracts. One would expect a Czech conductor to have insights into a nationalistic work that embodies so much of the country's history - real and legendary - that others might not have, and it shows.

Right from the gorgeous harp theme which opens Vysehrad one feels involved and not just waiting for the bits with the tunes in them as some performances become. In Vltava the sound picture is beautifully drawn, the sense of movement being almost tangible from the rippling strings and woodwinds. The strings portrayal of the shimmering moonlight before the rapids was especially noteworthy.

Sarka tells of the eponymous heroine whose revenge on men is the basis of the legend. With hints of only partly explored themes it sounds like a blueprint for a longer, unwritten work. Alert strings, some fine brass playing and busy percussion, make this piece in some ways the most interesting of the set. From Bohemia's Meadows and Fields with its deservedly popular 'big tune' is an undoubted success. Supported by an ultra responsive group of musicians Pesek is able to linger, as he does, over the well-known melody yet inject a lively tempo into the polka-like passages. The orchestra really shines here with superb upper string playing and glowing woodwinds and horns in the chorale.

Tabor and Blanik, the two final sections, are separate but with a musical link. Tabor's hushed, eerie opening and heavy brass chording make a powerful effect prior to the first entry of the Hussite hymn tune which joins the two sections. Blanik shows more beautiful wind and horn playing.

The recording is first rate, with depth in a natural sounding ambience, vividness and it shows off the R.L.P.O. to great advantage. Highly recommended.

Sadly, the second CD is something of a disappointment. Libor Pesek switches to the Czech Philharmonic in three works by Dvorak recorded in Prague. Neither in performance nor content does the grouping match its companion disc.

The main work is Dvorak's D Minor Fourth Symphony, dating from 1874 but not performed until 18 years later. The first movement's attractive lilting theme lacks a degree or two of lightness. The horns and tubas at the opening of the slow second movement reflect Wagner's strong influence - a near copy of a theme from Tannhauser follows. This Andante as played is stolid and slightly inflexible, and dare I say, dull. In the final two movements the lightness of touch which had been lacking so far appears and the work takes off to some degree. The Scherzo is finely driven and the vigorous Finale concludes a performance best described as patchy.

Dvorak's melodic gifts shine in his Czech Suite of 1879 - a short five movement work of considerable charm with much folk based material. Pastoral music in essence, here given a beautifully pointed performance full of rhythmic vitality with notably some first rate woodwind playing heard clearly in a beautifully textured recording. In the hands of an all Czech team its appeal becomes obvious. A little winner. The overture My Home which completes the disc reflects Dvorak's nationalism in a performance which plays an occasional piece for its full worth.

The Czech recording is bright and open with clear textures.

Reviewer

Harry Downey

CD1

CD2

 


Reviewer

Harry Downey

CD1

CD2


Reviews from previous months


Reviews carry sales links but you can also purchase from:

Return to Index