Classical Editor: Rob Barnett
 

Music Webmaster
Len Mullenger: Len@musicweb-international.com


SCHUMANN: 'Carnaval': arr. Ravel, Kinderjahr: arr. Adorno. Symphony No. 2 in C major Op. 61.   Royal Philharmonic Orchestra Dirk Joeres BIS CD-1055 63m DDD.

Save around 22% with
Crotchet
Amazon UK
Amazon US


 

You may be thinking, Why is BIS issuing yet another Schumann Symphony cycle, surely we are well served by Gardiner's outstanding new DG set? The answer lies in the couplings; newly discovered orchestral arrangements of the composer's piano pieces, interesting and intriguing makeweights in their own right and deserving of re-incarnation. Joeres is a fiery conductor and his tempi for the Carnaval pieces show that the music is not that suited to an orchestral guise. Still, much fun is to be found in the Paganini piece whilst the Davidsbundler march comes across perennially well. The same goes for the exquisite 'Kinderjahr', a true study in harmony and invention The Mendelssohn movement is particularly charming whilst 'Kmecht Ruprecht' is also very beautiful. With the symphony I turned to my trusty old Sawallisch version, which won me over in my days of youth! Although Joeres and the RPO are evidently much attuned to this Cinderella-like score, there is none of the unique vision that is constantly flowing through the Dresden version. However, Joeres holds the structural flow well enough and his dreamy Adagio espressivo is very beautiful where it is so easy to lose interest. A fiery Finale tips the balance slightly but again, Sawallisch is quite difficult to beat. The BIS recording is outstandingly clear and focused whilst the programme notes are keen and highly informative. It will obviously depend on the couplings if you already own one of the many Schumann symphony sets around.

Reviewer

Gerald Fenech

Performance:

Sound:

Reviewer

Gerald Fenech

Performance:

Sound:


Reviews from previous months


Reviews carry sales links but you can also purchase from:

Return to Index