Classical Editor: Rob Barnett
 

Music Webmaster
Len Mullenger: Len@musicweb-international.com



Gustav MAHLER
Symphony No.5 in c sharp minor

Dallas Symphony Orchestra
Conducted by Andrew Litton
Dorian DOR-90193  [71.00]
Crotchet
 Amazon UK  Amazon USA

This "live" recording of Mahler's Fifth Symphony dates from 1993 but has come to me alongside two newer Mahler recordings by Andrew Litton. This was the first collaboration between Litton and the Dallas Symphony following his appointment as Musical Director and I have to say at the outset that it would have been better if it had been left in the archives. The start is not promising in that the funeral march needs more power and reach than it gets here. What emerges is more wistful than tragic with no apparent idea of great events being debated and an orchestra that appears to have little idea of a Mahler sound. Then at the crucial "jump-off" at bar 155 (which Mahler marks "Suddenly faster. Passionate. Wild") there's nowhere near enough propulsion or drama to justify the composer's intentions. "Tentative" is the word that springs to mind with the important violin runs half-hearted too. Things don't improve. The return of the funeral material is under-characterised and the plunging descent at the close (marked "Lamenting") is a very damp squib. In the second movement the chattering woodwinds, so evocative during bars 64-74 against lyrical lower strings, don't penetrate the texture and the strings themselves hardly curl around their music like they can be made to. A fault carried on with the "monody of the lamenting cellos" at 188-213. More evidence of a lack of understanding of ebb and flow in this symphony's special nature. Structurally Litton builds to the climax of this movement quite well and the brass makes a fine noise, but nothing that can remotely touch other versions of this work. This movement also exposes an aspect of the sound recording that I didn't like. The lower registers are a bit diffuse and hollow which tends to blunt the special sound of this symphony further.

Mahler said that conductors would ruin the Scherzo by playing it too quickly. A shrewd remark but I don't believe he would have liked to hear it played so sluggishly as this. In passages of repose the performance seems to wander about with no real impression anyone has much idea as to where things are going or why. There is so much variation and interest to be found in this amazing movement - the hub of the symphony's wheel - but Litton seems oblivious, or unable to get the orchestra to reflect that. The Adagietto begins well with a flowing tempo but I felt the strings, at least as they reproduce, don't show evidence of the special mixture of nostalgia and tension Mahler was aiming for here. Litton also slows down markedly in the second half, more than I think Mahler's markings demand of him. By the last movement I'm afraid all is lost and all that's worth reporting is that the notes appear to be in the right place.

Any attempt at the subtle interplay of darkness and light, positive and negative emotions in opposition, all so important in this work, are missing. This is a lacklustre, dull and pedestrian recording that should have been quietly forgotten about and from which no one emerges with much distinction.

Reviewer

Tony Duggan

Performance:

Recording:

 



Reviewer

Tony Duggan

Performance:

Recording:


Reviews from previous months


You can purchase CDs, tickets and musician's accessories and Save around 22% with these retailers :

BlackStar.co.uk - The UK's Biggest Video Store


Concert and Show tickets

Ticketlinks

Musicians accessories

Click here to visit piedog.com



Return to Index