Other Links
Editorial Board
- UK Editors
- Roger Jones and John Quinn
Editors for The Americas - Bruce Hodges and Jonathan Spencer Jones
European Editors - Bettina Mara and Jens F Laurson
Consulting Editor - Bill Kenny
Assistant Webmaster -Stan Metzger
Founder - Len Mullenger
Google Site Search
SEEN AND HEARD UK CONCERT REVIEW
Rachmaninov: The Bells, Op. 35
Walton: Symphony No 1 in B flat minor
'The Bells', Op. 35, was composed by Rachmaninov in 1912-1913. It
therefore came after the First and Second symphonies, but before the
Third. In many ways it can be considered to be Rachmaninov's Choral
Symphony; it has four movements, and calls for a huge orchestra, a
choir, and three soloists; soprano, tenor and baritone. The text is
Edgar Allan Poe's, 'The Bells', freely translated into Russian by
Konstantin Balmont, a prominent Russian poet. It is reputed to have been
one of Rachmaninov's favourite compositions.
This is top-drawer Rachmaninov, showing him to be a true successor to
Tchaikovsky, the composer he revered. In other words it is passionate,
sometimes sombre, sometimes tortured, and sometimes utterly sublime. The
use of the orchestra is brilliantly virtuosic, alive with brilliantly
vivid colours, and always sure-footed. Rachmaninov's extraordinary
harmonic sense is here in abundance - glowingly chromatic, yet always
with a firm sense of direction.
This was a fabulous performance. Bychkov obviously adores the music, and
directed the orchestra, choir, and soloists firmly but lovingly. Frank
Lopardo sang the first movement, 'Silver Sleigh Bells', with sure
intonation and a radiant tone, semi-eclipsed only by the BBC Symphony
Chorus, whose contribution was nothing short of breathtaking. Next it
was the turn of Viktoria Yastrebova to sing the second movement, 'Mellow
Wedding Bells'. The choral writing here is more solemn, and it contrasts
with ecstatic music for the solo soprano. As in the previous movement
the solo part was superbly performed.
The third movement, 'Loud alarum Bells', is for chorus and orchestra,
and here we're in a different world again, with dark colours and
dramatic rhythms. Both chorus and orchestra continued to shine, and then
we were plunged into the desolation of the last movement, 'Mournful Iron
Bells', sung by David Wilson-Johnson to enormously moving effect. In
this final movement the long, sad, cor anglais solo was beautifully
played by Alison Teale. Towards the very end, Rachmaninov pulls out a
master-stroke, and the music gently transports us into a major key;
peace reigns, beyond death.
I understand that David Wilson-Johnson was a late replacement for the
advertised soloist, Vladimir Vaneev. Regrettably, there was no
announcement to this effect and I only learned of it by chance during a
post-concert conversation with a member of the orchestra.
It was exciting to contemplate Walton's very different First Symphony
after all this. Composed between 1931and 1935, it was instantly
recognized as a landmark, and it's not hard to see why. In it Walton
shows complete mastery of form and manages to be totally original,
despite showing strong influences of some other symphonic geniuses,
notably Elgar and above all, Sibelius. The first movement, with its
virtually ceaseless energy and jagged rhythms rivals Beethoven's 5th
in its use of a rhythmic leitmotif - it is extraordinarily
concentrated, dramatic and powerful. The second movement is a fast,
impatient scherzo, the third a reflective autumnal idyll, and the fourth
a bombastic affair, featuring extended fugato sections and a splendidly
triumphant coda.
Walton never found composing an easy business, struggling for months or
even years to get things right. He had particularly serious problems
with this last movement, so much so that the first performance had to be
given with only the first three movements completed. There has been much
speculation as to why Walton found it difficult to finish the symphony,
which came following a hugely upsetting love affair with Baroness Imma
Doernberg. Some say that it was a new love, Alice Wimborne, who enabled
the block to be cleared, but in any case it is clear that the first
three movements were very difficult to follow. Optimism was needed to
counterbalance the storms and stresses particularly apparent in
movements one and two, and optimism was in short supply in the
economically and politically troubled times of the 1930's.
In this fabulous music, Bychkov, who has been making a speciality of
this symphony, seemed less happy. Although the performance was certainly
interesting, with much committed playing from the BBC SO, I felt there
were problems with tempi, which sometimes threatened to undermine the
symphony's strong design. The all-important dotted rhythms in the first
movement began somewhat hesitantly, and there was too much rubato in the
later sections. The second movement was taken more slowly than is the
norm, and it simply felt too slow. The lyrical third movement fared
better, but again I felt the last movement was taken at too leisurely a
pace and excitement was lost. For me, this really did not compare with
one or two of the excellent performances available on disc, say, by
Vernon Handley, Previn, or even those by the composer himself.
Despite these gripes, this was a terrific concert, and it was gratifying
to see the Barbican Hall choc-a-bloc with an audience obviously
thrilling to the music.
Christopher Gunning
CG writes:
As a composer myself, attending
concerts is a necessary and lovely part of my life, and there is
nothing quite like the excitement of live music making. Periodically, as
with all of us, I’ve been cross, reading
reviews of concerts I’ve attended, often disagreeing with the mainstream
critics, and frequently feeling that the reviewer failed to convey the
essence of the music and of its performance. So it is interesting to
have a go at it myself - and the first thing I’ve discovered is that
it’s not necessarily easy! What I will aim to do is talk about the
composer and the music, and try to judge whether or not the composer
would have been content with the performance.
It’s inevitable that I will view things from the composer’s point of
view; I have been writing music for most of my life – mostly scores for
films and television, but more recently symphonies and concertos.
About my own career - my website can be found at
www.christopher-gunning.co.uk