Other Links
Editorial Board
- UK Editors
- Roger Jones and John Quinn
Editors for The Americas - Bruce Hodges and Jonathan Spencer Jones
European Editors - Bettina Mara and Jens F Laurson
Consulting Editor - Bill Kenny
Assistant Webmaster -Stan Metzger
Founder - Len Mullenger
Google Site Search
SEEN AND HEARD
INTERNATIONAL CONCERT REVIEWBach (arr. Webern), Berg, Beethoven: Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra, Kirill Karabits (conductor), Sergei Khachatryan (soloist); Town Hall, Cheltenham, 10.3.11. (RJ)
Bach (arr. Webern): Ricercar
Berg: Violin Concerto
Beethoven:
Symphony No 3 'Eroica'If concerts by the Bournemouth
Symphony Orchestra feature but rarely on this website, this does not
imply that the BSO's musical activities are unworthy of attention.
An ensemble which can count such icons as Marin Alsop, Yakov
Kreizberg and Andrew Litton among its past principal conductors is
clearly no "also ran"; and the latest occupant of this post, Kirill
Karabits, seems determined to add lustre to the orchestra's
reputation. Mr Karabits was shortlisted for the Royal Philharmonic
Society conductor's award last year. Need I say more?
If this particular concert is anything to go by, he has no
intention of "playing safe". Including just one work by a composer
of the Second Viennese School is likely to raise a few eyebrows even
in the 21st century,
but this programme featured two of them! Admittedly, Bach was the
inspiration for the first work - one of his ricercars
(master-fugues) from The
Musical Offering - but
while the notes in Webern's arrangement were Bach's, the idiom was
unmistakably Webern's. Melodic lines started by one instrument were
passed over to others - to the horns, the trombones or the solo
violin of the orchestra's guest leader, Jessica Mattheas - and tonal
colour predominated over the melodic structure. Mr Karabits was at
pains to bring out the delicacy of the music almost until the end
when the whole orchestra came together in a majestic
Baroque-sounding climax.
Berg's Violin
Concerto was
dedicated to Manon Gropius, Alma Mahler's daughter, who died at the
age of 18. It is a very personal work, particularly in the first
movement, regarded as an affectionate character sketch of the girl.
It opens tenderly with the violin playing above the harp followed by
the woodwind and then the cellos. Violinist Sergey Khachatryan
created a dreamlike atmosphere with his lyrical playing in the
andante section, becoming more rhapsodic and passionate in the
allegretto. The second movement had a more violent, anguished start
with harsh eruptions from the brass, but the anguish died down in
the cadenza where Mr Khachatryan's violin started quietly and then
seemed to soar heavenward. Turbulence returned in a raucous passage
where the full orchestra and soloist seemed to rail against the
injustice of Manon's untimely death, but was relieved by a tranquil
adagio with - miracle of miracles - the Bach chorale Es
ist genug, so nimm, Herr, meinen Geist as
accompaniment. This
was a fine, persuasive performance from the soloist matched by some
refined playing from the orchestra under Mr Karabits' excellent
direction.
I am not sure that Beethoven's Eroica was
the ideal companion to the other works on the programme. Clearly
,the promoters felt the need to include a popular work to pull in
the crowd, but to my ears it felt strangely old-fashoned after what
had preceded it. Nevertheless, I re-adjusted to the world of
tonality and found much to praise in the performance. Although
Kirill Karabits is a young man, there was nothing brash about his
interpretation of the work; indeed he seemed to dwell on the more
refined and reflective passages. Delicacy may be his stock-in-trade,
yet he unleashed plenty of power in the fugue in the second
movement. The Scherzo pulsated with nervous energy with the horns
distinguishing themselves in the trio, and he steered the orchestra
through the complexities of the finale with skill.
The Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra are clearly masters of the
standard repertoire, but they are obviously keen to embrace
interesting new challenges as well. For this reason we shall keep
them on our radar and attempt to offer them better coverage in
future.