Other Links
Editorial Board
- Editor - Bill Kenny
- London Editor-Melanie Eskenazi
- Founder - Len Mullenger
Google Site Search
SEEN AND HEARD INTERNATIONAL
CONCERT REVIEW
Jazz at
Lincoln
Center
Orchestra:
Wynton
Marsalis,
trumpet and
artistic
director.
Rose Theater,
New York,
20.10.2007 and
26.10.2007 (HS)
Though the role
of a jazz
composer and
arranger may
take a different
tack from that
of his
counterpart in
the classical
world, the ones
who excel at
their art can
produce music of
equal complexity
and spark
emotions
vividly. In
concerts this
past week, the
Jazz at Lincoln
Center Orchestra
and its leader,
trumpeter Wynton
Marsalis, played
music by two
20th century
jazz composers
and arrangers
who deserve
greater renown,
not least
because of
musical
inventiveness
and finesse that
parallel in
their own ways
the work of
their classical
brethren.
On a visit to
New York I made
a beeline for
Rose Theater in
the lavish Time
Warner Center
five blocks from
Lincoln Center.
It was built in
2004 as the
permanent home
for this jazz
band. Fifteen of
New York's best
jazz musicians
play music of
the past and
commissions new
pieces, just
like a modern
symphony
orchestra might.
In the hands of
these
technically
brilliant and
passionate
players, music
that may only be
heard on old LPs
comes to life.
The first of the
two concerts I
heard was a
tribute to Benny
Carter, who was
being inducted
posthumously
into the
orchestra's Hall
of Fame.
Carter's work
spanned the arc
of jazz from
before the dawn
of the swing era
in the 1930s
until his death
in 2003. He
wrote for a
series of his
own bands, then
for the likes of
Count Basie, and
for films such
as "An American
in Paris" and
"Stormy
Weather." Some
of his own tunes
are jazz
classics,
including "When
Lights Are Low"
and the novelty
song, "Cow Cow
Boogie."
The other
concert explored
the music of Gil
Evans, who added
instruments
nontraditional
for jazz to his
arrangements as
early as the
1940s, using
French horns,
bassoons, oboes
and a tuba. His
writing was more
complex than
Carter's. Evans
is most famous
for his work
with trumpeter
Miles Davis. In
the late 1950s
and 1960s they
recorded several
classic albums
in the jazz
idiom, including
"Birth of the
Cool" and
"Sketches of
Spain."
The Jazz at
Lincoln Center
Orchestra plays
with tight
intensity and
real swing. They
relish dynamic
changes and
shifts in tone,
bringing the
music to life
with technical
mastery the
original bands
could seldom
muster. The
musical
arguments in
these
arrangements
emerge in their
hands (and lips)
with high-def
clarity.
Marsalis, one of
the few jazz
musicians who
has achieved
success in the
classical world,
delivered
several
hauntingly
beautiful and
musically taut
solo
improvisations
in the concerts
I heard.
A jazz
arrangement
often comes out
as something
more than the
original music
that inspired
it, in essence a
new composition.
When Carter got
his hands on
"All of Me," a
song standard by
Seymour Simons,
it became an
interplay of
complex,
sometimes
contrapuntal
writing for the
five-saxophone
line,
interspersed
with passages
for the
trombones and
trumpets playing
together or
"talking to each
other" as
separate
sections.
Writing for jazz
means
incorporating
extended
improvisations
for soloists.
Carter was a
more traditional
jazzman and
wrote in a
straightforward
idiom that
alternated
ensemble writing
with solos.
Evans, who
counted the
avant-garde
composers Harry
Partch and John
Cage among his
friends, liked
to weave the
solos and
ensembles
together into
more subtle
forms.
One of the
highlights of
JALCO's Evans
concert was Kurt
Weill's "Bilbao
Song" (from the
1929 score to
"Happy End").
Evans arranged
it for a jazz
orchestra for
the 1959 "Out of
the Cool"
recording. He
starts with a
rattling,
medium-tempo
jazz beat on
drums and
maracas, the the
bass, guitar and
piano vamping
along. The tune,
slowed to a
crawl, plays
against it, the
instrumentation
and tone
changing with
each note
(perhaps
inspired by
Webern's
instrumentation
of the Bach
Ricercata a 6?).
Finally,
Marsalis' solo
trumpet enters,
at first playing
the tune more or
less as Weill
wrote it, then
expanding it
into ever more
complex
improvisations.
Meanwhile, the
band growls
along in
counterpoint.
Two arrangements
from Evans'
collaboration
with Davis on
Gershwin's score
to "Porgy &
Bess" featured
Marsalis on
"Gone," and
another member
of the trumpet
section, Ryan
Kisor, on "Gone,
Gone, Gone,"
which Evans
developed from
"My Man's Gone
Now" and the
trio "Bess Is
Gone." Rodgers
and Hart's
"Nobody's Heart"
(from "Jumbo")
melted into
swirls of color
in Evans'
delicate
arrangement,
which featured
an oboe solo.
Although Evans
was associated
with the
quieter, more
cerebral "West
Coast Jazz"
school, he could
also write
straightforward,
hard-swinging
arrangements.
"Sister Sadie,"
a gospel-tinged
piece by the
Hard Bop pianist
and composer
Horace Silver,
ended the first
half of the
concert with a
series of
joy-inducing
extended solos
and swinging,
rock solid
ensemble playing
to Evans'
impeccably
dressed music.
Adding to the
richness of the
music, between
pieces Marsalis
talked about
what the
composer/arranger
had been aiming
for. He showed
the same sort of
insight
communicative
conductors, such
as Leonard
Slatkin and
Michael Tilson
Thomas, bring to
symphony
concerts. There
are more
parallels
between jazz and
classical music
than most of us
realize.
Harvey Steiman