Mostly Mozart Festival: The arias that time
forgot.
Soloists / Academy of Ancient Music /
Paul Daniel (conductor).
Barbican
Hall, London.
28.07.2006
(ED)
Geraldine McGreevy
soprano
Amanda Roocroft
soprano
Sarah Tynan
soprano
Andrew Kennedy
tenor
Christopher Purves
bass
Mark Stone
bass
This penultimate concert
in the Barbican’s Mostly Mozart Festival, must have answered the prayers of
music lovers that have long tired of hearing the same works over and over again.
Unless one has recordings of Wolfgang’s concert arias on the shelves at home
there’s a chance that most, possibly all, the items on the programme for this
fully packed evening would have seemed relatively ‘new’ territory to explore. As
Paul Daniel pointed out in his introduction to the evening, it is not that the
music constitutes substandard Mozart – far from it – but that it is music he
wrote on a daily basis for singers he admired that perhaps accounts for its
relative obscurity nowadays. These insertion arias were often written to order
for specific vocal gifts and they can often be perceived today in much the same
way a symphony by Furtwängler or Klemperer is: worthy if a touch dull. This
concert showed how misplaced that judgemental assessment can be.
The concert presented
twenty arias, over a third of the insertion arias Mozart wrote. A number of
ensemble pieces broke up the sequence of solo numbers and helped to show the
variety of Mozart’s writing. They illustrated the need Mozart felt to turn his
hand to Italian opera on his travels around the courts of Europe despite being a
composer steeped in the Austro-German tradition. Despite this though it was
clearly apparent that in these items Mozart often sowed the seeds for characters
he would perfect in his own complete stage works. The seducing aristocrat,
buffoon husband, innocent servant girl and wronged husband all put in cameo
appearances. Two wholly Mozartian unfinished operatic projects were represented
to good effect: Lo sposo deluso, a buffo farce, and L’oca del Cairo
(The Cairo Goose), which Daniel accurately if humorously termed something of
‘an operatic turkey’.
The selection of singers
was of absolute importance to the success of the concert. The three sopranos
illustrated the degree of nuance Mozart even at a precociously early age
required from the vocal range. Geraldine McGreevy brought dramatic impetus to
bear in her singing of Vado, ma dove, one of the most well known of
Mozart’s insertion arias. Rich and evenly produced tone was the predominant
feature of Amanda Roocroft’s contributions. One sensed that her voice is one
that finds form more in the singing of Mozart than when subjected to the demands
of other composers. Coloratura brilliance was all Sarah Tynan’s domain, and hers
was the single most consistent contribution of the evening. Often filling the
shoes of Aloysia Lange, arguably Mozart’s favourite soprano and one of superior
skill, Tynan rose to the occasion in giving an account of Vorrei spiegarvi
that possessed poise that was unafraid to yield to the despair the text
contains. Beautifully shaped legato singing with a thread of voice found its
twin in an elegiac oboe solo. Most impressive.
Andrew Kennedy showed his
abilities at comic acting, conveying ignorance and stupidity with ease in Con
ossequio, con rispetto. Christopher Purves seemed destined to spend the
evening veering between the buffo and the petty aristocrat, both of which he was
vocally at home with. Mark Stone, whom I had not previously thought of as
terribly charismatic in terms of stage presence (it could be that I had not seen
him in entirely suitable roles), left his mark with Rivolgete a lui lo
sguardo. Composed as an alternative aria for Guglielmo in Cosí, it’s a
coarse and insinuating number – and no wonder it was dropped in the end by
Mozart himself – but Stone served it well in his wry humorous touches that took
away some of its edge.
The final word though was
Mozart’s, in a German aria that conveyed with very personal passion something of
his thoughts on being a composer forced by circumstance to write outside his
natural environment for the pleasure of others. Language, music, being and
identity become inseparable in the world of opera, lest any performer or
audience ever forget it.
Paul Daniel directed the
Academy of Ancient Music from the keyboard and appeared to enjoy the experience
immensely. Certainly he brought out much wonder in the arias themselves through
sensitive accompaniment of all the singers. The AAM’s playing was finely graded
and responsive to each item, if occasionally one might have liked a more
intuitive inflection to individual lines. That no doubt would come with repeated
playing of this music. There’s no doubt that given the general standard of
advocacy even Wolfgang’s lesser vocal compositions deserve greater attention
than they often receive.
Evan Dickerson