Schubert: Ian Bostridge (tenor),
Julius Drake (piano), Queen Elizabeth Hall, London, 28.11.2005
(AO)
The annual series “Song
on the South Bank” opened with Ian Bostridge
and Julius Drake. Tonight’s
programme came in two halves.
The first half was conceptually brilliant, exploring
settings of poets who were outsiders and misfits.
It was powerfully performed, so much so that it was
profoundly disturbing. In
a smaller, more intimate venue and with an audience of Kenner, it would have been momentous. But
an evening of sad songs about death is never going to wow
the public. Artistry, alas, needs a touch of showmanship
to succeed.
The first five songs, to
the poems of Ernst Konrad Friedrich
Schulze were certainly not designed to get an audience in
party mood. Schulze conceived an obsessive love for two
sisters, one of whom was dead. Their strange haunted quality
highlights the disturbing nature of the poet’s delusions.
Bostridge sings them with
exquisite sensitivity. Der liebliche Sterne
was a masterpiece of subtle nuance, negotiating
the sudden swoops of high and low that reflect the
swings in the poet’s mood. The star is elusive, an unapproachable vision.
In the third verse, he manages to move from awed rapture,
to a gnawing sense of frustration. The song ends with unrestrained violence. Bostridge throws out Herneider ins Wogengewühle! (Down into the whirlpool!) with such conviction that it seems perfectly logical that the poet should want to drown himself to
reach a star. Drake
plays the postlude with bittersweet irony: the twinkling “starlight”
notes remain as intangible as the poet’s dreams.
Even when Schubert switches
to a major key, he doesn’t disguise the undercurrents. As Richard Stokes, in the unusually well written
programme notes, says “the ritornellos…… drive the lover nearly
insane”. Drake was
superb, giving the circular rhythms manic intensity, completely
undermining the süßes Ahnen (sweet
expectations) in the text.
Bostridge and Christoph
Prégardien both made pioneering
recordings of Schubert’s settings of Johann Mayrhofer. When Bostridge sang Im kalten,
rauhen Norden
(in the cold, raw North), his voice curled chillingly round
the repeated “en”s, then suddenly burst with glowing warmth in einer Sonnenstadt.
The effect was almost visual.
Describing the sun, his voice became raptly plangent,
reminding me of the unnatural calm of Schulze’s starstruck
gaze. Drake further emphasized the darker undercurrents,
sometimes stridently dominant, sometimes going subterranean
behind the voice, but never subsumed.
Death was to the nineteenth
century what sex is to ours.
So thus followed three more songs in which death is
seen as blissful release.
Bostridge and Drake negotiated
the tricky pauses in Totengräbers Heimweh, which express wordlessly the gravediggers constant sighs.
If Bostridge threw a little
too much abandon into Tag
und Nacht keine
Ruh! he captured the poem’s demented mood. The new depth in his voice helped him scrape
along the lowest parts of his register.
When he intoned Hinab, ins tiefe Grab (down into the deep grave) the chameleon quality
of his voice sounded almost un-human, like a tolling bell. Bostridge sang the
final verse with an exquisitely delicate ardour as if the
gravedigger were already shining with the stars before he
collapses, lifeless but blissful, into an empty grave.
It was profoundly disturbing because it was so convincing,
and deeply felt. So unsettling, indeed, I wanted a strong
drink at the interval.
The second half of the programme
was much more conventional, with all time favourites. There was much beauty, but it was hard to shake
off the profound experience that had gone before. It must have been even more difficult for performers
of Bostridge’s sensitivity. His Sei mir gegrüßt was caressingly
decorated, but infused with too much wistful languor. The poet, Friedrich Rückert,
may have written much about death, but in this case he was
being fairly straightforward.
Drake, Bostridge’s partner for a dozen years, seemed to sense the
need to change the mood.
He bounced into Die
Forelle with surprising attack,
making it a jaunty, cheeky dance. Bostridge responded
almost with relief. There
was more lyrical singing to follow.
Des Fischers Liebesglück in particular stands out. But my mind was still dwelling on the astounding,
if depressing, earlier songs.
Anne
Ozorio