Seen and Heard
Donizetti, Pia de’
Tolomei Soloists, Geoffrey Mitchell Choir, London
Philharmonic Orchestra/David Parry, RFH, Saturday, October 23rd, 2004
The week preceding this concert performance of rare Donizetti was
taken up with recording sessions. To present Pia de’Tolomei
at all is a work of substantial musicological archaeology: it was
not published complete during the composer’s lifetime and the
critical edition was only published this year.
Pia has a complex performance history anyway, given that the Act I
finale incurred the displeasure of its initial audience (Teatro Apollo,
Venice, on February 18th, 1837) and so the composer, ever willing
to oblige, created a revision for Senigallia. The reason for all this
background is to point out that the concert performance we heard was
based on the original Venetian text, but with the Senigallia Act I
ending, thus presenting Donizetti’s last thought on the matter,
although the recording will present the original. Interestingly, the
libretto we were provided with did not entirely follow what we heard.
A disorienting cut very early on did not help confidence (in fairness
there were only a couple of other, shorter, cuts).
Pia was resurrected in 1967, in Siena. It was even heard in London
in 1978, but presumably never since. Which is a shame. The story is
a tragic one, set in the year 1260. Right at the beginning, Pia has
been sent away from Siena to a castle for her own protection because
of ongoing wars. This is a story of mistaken identity and motive.
Pia’s husband, Nello, has intercepted a letter in which an assumed
lover describes an intended meeting with Pia. To complicate matters,
Nello’s cousin, Ghino dell’ Armieri, tries to engineer
a situation in which Pia is caught out as Ghino has himself had his
amorous advances rejected by Pia.
The mysterious visitor is none other than Rodrigo de’ Tolomei,
Pia’s brother. Rodrigo languishes in prison, but is freed by
a bribed guard. Alas, Pia is incarcerated in a castle in marshlands
of the Maremma, where Nello intends she should contract malaria. Rodrigo
races to rescue his beloved; meanwhile Ghino tries his luck again,
learning in the process of his mistake in thinking her brother a beau.
Instruction is then received from Nello to put Pia to death at dawn,
unless said instruction is revoked.
A mandatory storm and (the greatest contradiction of them all) a Chorus
of Hermits set the weather. Ghino - at the last moment after having
been fatally wounded - reveals his mistake, begging for forgiveness
from Nello. Nello refuses forgiveness, but rushes to the castle to
arrive before dawn. Needless to say he is too late. Pia has drunk
poison; (re-enter) Rodrigo. Just before she dies, Pia manages to reconcile
husband and brother.
Just about all the ingredients you could want with plenty of scope
for florid, expressive arias, and even a Mad Scene. Such a challenge
needs a strong line-up of singers. Some Opera Rara favourites of course
were here, but what struck one more forcibly was the consistently
excellent diction of every single singer.
Pia herself was Majella Cullagh, strong and confident. Her legato
was superb, her high register magnificent and her way with Donizetti’s
fast-moving lines as to the manner born. Perhaps her finest moment
came towards the end, in the dark aria, ‘Ah! La pietade, o Ghino’,
almost heart-breakingly tender in its expressive scope. Her brother
Rodrigo is actually sung by a female (mezzo), here the truly excellent
Manuala Custer, who almost upstaged the heroine. A protegée
of Katia Ricciarelli, Custer has previously appeared on Opera Rara
in Rossini’s Zelmira. She has a remarkably strong, yet agile,
instrument in her voice, and was superbly expressive in her aria,
‘In questa de’ viventi orrida tomba’. Rodrigo’s
vengeance aria in Act II, ‘Tremenda folgore il brando mia sarà’,
revealed how strong her upper register is, also. When Pia and Rodrigo
were heard in duet, magic was the result.
Bruce Ford took the part of Ghino. He was expressive, and his voice
held enough beauty to make a creditable assumption. Roberto Servile’s
Nello was preferable though and it was nice to hear a baritone with
an imposing depth to the voice. His Act I aria, ‘Parea celeste
spirito’ was one of the evening’s highlights. Marco Vinco’s
Lamberto was marvellously warm-toned.
Even the smaller roles were well parted, from a well-projected tenor
Prison Guard (Christopher Turner) to Mark Wilde’s velvet-toned
yet authoritative Ubaldo (only later on did his tone become thinner)
and Mirco Palazzi’s rounded Piero (one of the hermits).
The recording is eagerly awaited.
Back to the Top
to the Index Page